Postby Indigo » Thu Aug 13, 2009 1:10 am
I'm new to this trading system, and have read as much as I've had time to. Still, I have some fundamental questions that I would greatly appreciate help with from the Author or someone with lots of experience using the system.
Last night I did two trades E/U and U/J. In both cases, the H1 chart had a 3 semaphore, and the 15 had a 3 semaphore in the same direction on the previous candle. I entered on the 15 when I thought best, both times not too far from the 3 on the H1. Both trades ended up hitting my 15 pip stop loses as the semaphores moved down to the next candle (See my entry on the attached picture - the semaphore moved down from the candle I entered on). The system did not indicate "Do Not Reverse" on the H1 or M15 charts
I think there is promise with this, but I am concerned about the moving of the semaphores.
Here are some specific questions:
1. If the system does not say "Do Not Reverse", when can we say a semaphore is an accurate signal and is unlikely to move? That's the most difficult thing for me to grasp about this system.
2. I've noticed for very brief moments the indicator will say "OK to Short" or similar - is that the ONLY time to enter? If so, does it need to say that on both the M15 & H1 Charts, or just the M15?
3. What technical conditions result in the "OK to short" (or Buy) signal, and which cause the "Do Not Reverse" signal?
4. What is the difference between the 1, 2, and 3 semaphores, and what technical conditions cause them to appear?
5. Does anyone successfully use semaphores in other time frames, such as the D1, or should we ignore those in other than the M15 and H1 timeframes? Reason I ask is that sometimes there are conflicting indications across times frames, like a 3 suggesting a reverse to the upside on the H1 and a 3 to the downside on the D1.
6. Does anyone have a particular system they use with a high success rate? I figure I need 20 PIPS per day average gain to reach my objectives, anything you can share is greatly appreciated.
Thanks in advance for the courtesy of helping me with my questions!