PA, S/R, ZL, EXTREMES & MOMO

PebbleTrader · Post by **PebbleTrader** » Wed Sep 14, 2011 3:53 pm

Jalarupa,

Have you verified that it is plotting correctly?

I'll do it tonight if not, but my feed is likely different than yours.

PebbleTrader · Post by **PebbleTrader** » Wed Sep 14, 2011 3:55 pm

I have spent the past many hours looking for more solutions with not much luck.

I have gotten pretty far out on the Google searching...

PebbleTrader · Post by **PebbleTrader** » Wed Sep 14, 2011 4:07 pm

Just throwing this out as an idea, had not looked into it any further:

export the 1min history from MT4 to .csv I had seen some excel programs that will use an import of .csv and plot the PnF automatically from that...

Jalarupa · Post by **Jalarupa** » Wed Sep 14, 2011 4:16 pm

PebbleTrader wrote:Jalarupa,

Have you verified that it is plotting correctly?

I'll do it tonight if not, but my feed is likely different than yours.

Haven't had a chance to back test it so to speak... but what I can say is jforex plots on a price line breach... Not a fill... so I guess it would not be exactly what peeps would want...

[edit] having said that... surely its open to interpretation. As when a line a breached, the previous box is full so I guess this way you would be making a new X or O prematurely on the strength of the previous box's fullness... if that makes any sense to anyone, but me... wait a minute... ehhh... okay, yes...

flinux · Post by **flinux** » Wed Sep 14, 2011 6:49 pm

P&F has super-improved my trading.
Thank you, guys !!!!

PebbleTrader · Post by **PebbleTrader** » Thu Sep 15, 2011 3:51 am

"Haven't had a chance to back test it so to speak... but what I can say is jforex plots on a price line breach... Not a fill... so I guess it would not be exactly what peeps would want...

[edit] having said that... surely its open to interpretation. As when a line a breached, the previous box is full so I guess this way you would be making a new X or O prematurely on the strength of the previous box's fullness... if that makes any sense to anyone, but me... wait a minute... ehhh... okay, yes..."

I don't think there is a RIGHT WAY or WRONG WAY. The important thing to know is how and what it is doing. Most importantly, is it CONSISTENT?

So far I'm leaning towards doing it manually, as crazy as that sounds, but I'm still reviewing options. MANUALLY WILL BE A LAST RESORT!

Jalarupa · Post by **Jalarupa** » Thu Sep 15, 2011 4:38 am

Consistent...? well it looks like it

Place this one yesterday via limit order off the HUGE resistance area depicted in the last couple of days postings in red...

As of this post we are 63 pips in the green and only took 9 pips of heat...

Bowl me over with a feather... this may be the holy grail after all... Charles Dow and his buddies might have been onto something... indeed... the secret to killing the market is not time... but PRICE...

PebbleTrader · Post by **PebbleTrader** » Thu Sep 15, 2011 7:09 am

EUR/USD: 10x2 (from a 30s chart)

With breaches

Without breaches

Can you SEE why we might want to use brushing to brush in the breaches?

:shock:

PebbleTrader · Post by **PebbleTrader** » Thu Sep 15, 2011 7:15 am

A breach will occur 95+% of the time.

As was the case in the above plotting.

However, next time I will probably limit a breach plot to >33-50%.

:!:

PebbleTrader · Post by **PebbleTrader** » Thu Sep 15, 2011 7:21 am

PS, those were plotted "the correct way" this time.

You can use it to compare against your indi's your using...